Job Fairs Are Least Effective Job Search Tool, Popular In Tight Market

Thousands Flock to Job Fairs in Tight Market

While job fairs are considered to be among the least effective job search methods, thousands of frustrated and desperate job seekers acrossAmerica attend these events in the hopes of landing a position.  While the odds are stacked against the typical job-fair attendee, one employment expert says there are steps one can take to improve his or her chances, albeit slightly.

“The allure of the job fair is that you have a large number of employers under one roof; presumably, all with open positions to fill.  However, the number of job seekers at the fair is likely to far exceed the number of available jobs.  You are basically taking a leap of faith that you will stand out in the sea of candidates flowing by the recruiter’s booth” said John A. Challenger, chief executive officer of global outplacement consultancy Challenger, Gray & Christmas, Inc.

“Even if you do manage to make an impression on a recruiter, in most cases, it simply gets you to the next stage of the recruiting process, which most likely involves further screening of the selected candidates to determine the 10-15 individuals to bring in for a more formal interview at the company.”

Challenger is not the only one who believes job fairs are ineffective.  In a 2009 Challenger survey, in which human resources executives were asked to rate the effectiveness of various job-search methods on a scale of 1 (least effective) to 5 (most effective), job fairs ranked as the least effective job-search method, scoring an average rating of 1.6.

Challenger acknowledges that most job seekers fully understand the bleak odds of finding employment through a job fair, but flock to them out of desperation in this frustratingly tight job market.

In August, more than 3,000 job seekers flooded anAtlantajob fair hosted by the two Georgia Congressmen and the Congressional Black Caucus.  The job seekers were vying for positions at the 90 employers in attendance, all of which had job openings to fill.

Earlier this month, an estimated 5,000 people turned out for the JobQuest Job Fair inHonolulu,Hawaii.  Many of those in attendance were military veterans hoping to find positions at one of the employers specifically looking to hire former military personnel.

In Park Ridge,Illinois, nearly 1,000 people attended a relatively brief four-hour job fair in the hopes of landing a position with one of the 63 employers represented.

Despite the slim odds for success, Challenger does not suggest that job seekers entirely dismiss job fairs.

“The employers attending are usually there to fill specific openings.  The chances of them hiring you are small, but the chances of them hiring you are zero if you don’t show up at all.  In this job market, many job seekers are correctly deciding that a small chance is better than no chance,” said Challenger.

There are steps you can take to increase the odds of success at a job fair, according to Challenger.

“You cannot go in blind or without a plan.  It is important that you know which employers will be there and the types of positions they are trying to fill.  Only visit those that align with your objectives.  If there is an opportunity to interact with the recruiter, time will be limited.  So, it is critical to have a succinct script that highlights your skills, experience and strengths,” advised Challenger.

“It is also critical to maintain a positive and upbeat attitude throughout the job fair.  You may already be carrying a lot of frustration related to your job situation.  That frustration may be heightened by the job fair process, which typically has you waiting in long lines, surrounded by others who are equally frustrated.  This frustration, while natural and understandable, should not be on display at any point during the job fair.  Anything short of a bright and cheery attitude is likely to eliminate you from consideration,” he added.

“Most importantly, don’t put all of your job-search eggs in the job-fair basket.  A successful job search requires a multifaceted approach.  Those who rely on just one tool will take longer to find a position, even if it is networking, which is considered by many to be the most effective job-search strategy.  So, by all means, attend every job fair that comes to town.  But, don’t neglect the other tools at your disposal, such as online job boards, networking groups, social and professional networking websites, newspaper ads, and simply cold-calling employers,” Challenger concluded.

Go here for 2009 survey results on job search methods.


  • Dress as if you were going to an interview. Wear neat, pressed clothes and shined shoes. Cover tattoos, if possible.  No visible body piercings (other than earrings on women).
  • Smile.  This is your chance to make your best first impression.  Remember your image: I am a professional, I have no problems, I will create no problems, and I will solve all your problems.
  • Be yourself.  Don’t play a role, but be your best self.
  • Shake hands. Be enthusiastic. Show interest in the company and the company representative.  Know what the company does.
  • Sell yourself. Treat this like an interview.  Tell the company representative what kind of employee you are, what you can do for a company and give some examples of each.
  • Make sure you understand each company’s application procedure, whether paper or on-line.  Ask for a business card for proper information.  Fill out applications completely and neatly.  Include a copy of your resume when returning the application.
  • Approach each employer’s table by yourself, not with a friend or as part of a group.
  • Bring plenty of resumes. Put them in a folder or portfolio so they don’t get crushed.  You can also use the folder to hold any brochures, literature, applications and business cards you collect.  Don’t give out your resume right away.  Talk to the company representative first.
  •  Remember to be positive, prepared, polite and polished.


3 thoughts on “Job Fairs Are Least Effective Job Search Tool, Popular In Tight Market

  1. Pingback: Job Fairs Are Great PR For Politicians But Ineffective Otherwise « Paul Wolf

  2. Pingback: Job Fairs Are Great PR For Politicians But Ineffective Otherwise |

  3. Pingback: Recruiting Agency South East - Why Job Fairs Stink — and the Superior Recruiting Alternatives - Fiycore Staffing

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s